Waterproof vs Water Resistant Boots: What's the Difference?

When venturing out into the winter elements, you need the right footwear. Whether you're hiking through a snowy forest, dodging puddles during your commute in the city, or trekking across muddy trails, the choice you make between waterproof and water resistant boots will have a major impact. Choose correctly and your experience will be one of comfort, warmth, and safety. 

It’s worth noting that there is a common misconception between the terms “waterproof” and “water resistant.” Many people assume these terms are interchangeable. This invariably leads to misguided boot selection, which can leave your feet wet, cold, and uncomfortable. In this comprehensive guide, we'll clarify the distinctions between waterproof and water resistant boots and arm you with the knowledge to make your next boot purchase a well-informed one!

What Are Waterproof Boots?

Waterproof boots are specially engineered to provide an effective barrier against all water infiltration. Unlike their water resistant counterparts, insulated waterproof boots are constructed to completely prevent water penetration, ensuring that your feet remain dry and comfortable in even the wettest conditions. 

Materials Used

This protection, of course, all begins with the materials used in making your boots. Here are some of the most common:

• Gore-Tex - A membrane with microscopic pores that are too small for liquid water to penetrate but large enough to allow water vapor (like sweat) to escape, ensuring both dryness and breathability.
  
  
• Rubber - Natural and synthetic rubbers are innately impermeable and thus a very popular choice for waterproof boots. 
  
  
• Polyurethane (PU) coatings - Polyurethane is often applied to the exterior surfaces of boots to enhance water resistance. PU is known for its durability and water-repellent qualities.

Construction Techniques

The materials are only as good as their implementation. There are a few construction & design methods that boot manufacturers use to create a waterproof seal:  

• Seam-sealed construction - By their very nature, seams (where two or more different materials or segments of a boot meet) are natural weak points. It is from these points that water poses the greatest threat of seeping through. To combat this risk, the seams are coated with special tapes or sealants, then heated, to make boots waterproof. 
  
  
• Gusseted tongues - The tongue and adjacent lacing area of a boot represent another potential entry point for water. To counter this risk, waterproof boots often feature gusseted tongues. These tongues are attached to the sides of the boot's upper and create a continuous waterproof barrier. In concert with other technologies like waterproof membranes, gusseted tongues offer an additional layer of defense against moisture.

Understanding the materials and construction techniques used in waterproofing is essential to choosing the pair of boots that’s best suited to your needs. 

What Are Water Resistant Boots?

Water resistant boots offer a different level of protection against moisture. It’s important to note, however, that while water resistant boots are designed to repel water to some degree, they’re not the same as waterproof boots. They’re best suited to environments with light moisture exposure or settings in which they’re not exposed to much more than the occasional splash. While they don’t provide the same protection as waterproof snow boots in wet terrain or heavy rain, they’re an excellent choice for practical, everyday wear.

This, of course, is due to the use of materials and construction techniques different from those employed for fully waterproof boots.

Materials Used

• Treated leather - Water resistant boots are often made with leather that has been specially treated to enhance its water-repelling capabilities. These treatments create a “hydrophobic” surface. This does not mean that your boots harbor a secret fear of the elements. Hydrophobic surfaces cause water to bead up and roll off the boot, rather than absorb it.
  
  
• Nylon - A synthetic material known for its resistance to moisture, which helps to repel water while maintaining breathability.
  
  
• Durable water repellent (DWR) coatings - The outer layer of many water resistant boots features DWR coating. These coatings cause water to bead up and roll off the boot's surface, rather than soaking into the material.

Construction Techniques

• Tighter stitching - The stitching on water resistant boots is tighter & stronger than standard footwear to minimize the gaps between stitches and potential entry points for water.
  
  
• Water resistant zippers - Some water resistant boots are equipped with special water resistant zippers, while others have protective flaps that cover the zippers to prevent water from seeping in.

Key Differences Between Waterproof & Water-Resistant Boots

There are fundamental differences between waterproof and water resistant boots. The choices we make in prioritizing absolute waterproofing, breathability, durability, or ease of maintenance have a major impact on our comfort and boot performance in the cold, snowy elements. Let’s see how they compare to one another.

Performance in Wet Conditions

Waterproof boots excel in extreme wet conditions, providing reliable protection even during prolonged exposure. They’re designed to keep your feet warm, dry, and comfortable in heavy rain, standing water, and damp environments. Water resistant boots, on the other hand, offer greater versatility than full waterproof boots but only moderate protection against heavy rain or full immersion.

Breathability

Waterproof boots sometimes compromise breathability due to the specialized materials and techniques used in their construction. In ensuring that they keep your feet dry and warm, they can sometimes trap some moisture from sweat. Water resistant boots, meanwhile, generally offer better breathability, as they’re designed to effectively wick away moisture during everyday situations, in less inclement weather conditions.

Durability and Maintenance

Waterproof boots, especially those facing sustained exposure to harsh conditions and wear & tear,  require regular maintenance to preserve their waterproofing properties. Routine cleaning and reapplication of waterproofing treatments are essential to ensure continued performance. Though water resistant boots demand less maintenance, some care is still required to maintain their water-repelling capabilities. This typically involves the periodic reapplication of DWR (Durable Water Repellent) sprays.

Practical Applications

Considering what you need and expect out of a pair of boots is central to making a well-informed choice. In our cases here, understanding the differences in practical application between waterproof and water resistant boots is crucial.

When to Choose Waterproof Boots

If your outdoor adventures take place on muddy trails or worksites in cold and frequently rainy or snowy conditions, you should choose waterproof boots. This is also true if your activities involve navigating small bodies of water like stream crossings or wetlands. In any of these cases, a high-quality pair of fully waterproof boots will provide the warmth, comfort and protection you need, even in the most challenging conditions.

When to Choose Water Resistant Boots

In less demanding situations, meanwhile, water resistant boots are a more practical and appropriate choice. This involves everyday urban wear and short strolls or hikes in damp conditions, and in areas with sporadic rainfall. Additionally, in regions with warmer temperatures with high humidity, the superior breathability and reduced bulk of water resistant boots will allow your feet to breathe more easily without sacrificing water protection.

Care and Maintenance

By following a few care and maintenance guidelines tailored to your boot type, you can maximize the lifespan and protective properties of your waterproof or water resistant boots.

Waterproof Boots

Proper care for waterproof boots begins with making sure that you remove dirt, mud, and debris from your boots after every outdoor excursion. To do this, use a brush or a damp cloth to clean the exterior and prevent the buildup of grime. Also, to maintain the waterproofing capabilities of your boots, periodically apply a waterproofing agent or conditioner to the exterior to renew their water-repellent properties.

Finally, it’s crucial to avoid direct heat and allow the boots to dry naturally, in a well-ventilated area. It can be tempting to place your boots near a direct heat source to speed things up, but the excessive heat from a radiator or heater can compromise waterproofing.

Water Resistant Boots

Clean your water resistant boots regularly similarly, with a soft brush or cloth, to remove dirt and stains. This can go a long way in preserving the water resistant coating. Use a mild detergent when necessary. Over time, a boot’s water resistant coating begins to wear off. To restore water repellency, periodically reapply durable DWR sprays or treatments as recommended by the manufacturer. Also, to prevent degradation of the water resistant coating, store your boots in a cool, dry place away from excessive heat. 

In choosing between waterproof vs. water resistant boots, understanding the similarities and differences is pivotal. That’s because the right pair of boots does not just keep water out but also strikes the right balance between protection, breathability, warmth, and comfort. Armed with the proper knowledge, you are equipped to make an informed choice and invest in a pair of boots that aligns with your specific needs.

Where your adventures take you, stride forward with confidence!

Also in News